21 alumni…
- Prince Saunders (1775-1839)
- Moor's Charity School Class of 1808Educator, Pan-Africanist, and Advisor to Haiti's President
- Edward Mitchell (1794-1872)
- Class of 1828, A.B.First Black Graduate of the Ivy League and Baptist Clergyman
- Samuel Ford McGill (1815-1871)
- DMS Class of 1839, M.D.Physician, Businessman, and Liberian Politician
- George Torrance Gilliam (1801-1882)
- DMS Class of 1841, M.D.Physician in Pennsylvania, Illinois, and Missouri
- Thomas Paul, Jr. (1812-1885)
- Class of 1841, A.B.Garrison Abolitionist and African Free School Headmaster
- Pelleman M. Williams (1819-1882)
- Class of 1845Educator in New England and the postbellum South
- Henry Jenkins Roberts (1821-1863)
- DMS Class of 1846Physician, Liberian colonist and brother of Liberia's first President, Joseph Jenkins Roberts
- Dempsey Rollo Fletcher (1825-1878)
- DMS Class of 1847, M.D.Physician and Liberian colonist
- Augustus Washington (1821-1875)
- Class of 1847Daguerreotypist, Liberian Colonist, and Politician
- Isaac Humphrey Snowden (1826-1869)
- DMS Class of 1851, M.D.Physician and Liberian colonist
- Jonathan Clarkson Gibbs (1821-1874)
- Class of 1852, A.B.Clergyman, Abolitionist, and Reconstruction Politician
- Charles Benjamin Dunbar (1829-1878)
- DMS Class of 1853, M.D.Physician, politician and Liberian colonist
- James Parker Barnett (1831-1886)
- DMS Class of 1854, M.D.Physician in Brooklyn, New York
- Daniel Laing, Jr. (1824-1869)
- DMS Class of 1854, M.D.Physician and Liberian colonist
- Edward Garrison Draper (1834-1858)
- Class of 1855, A.B.First Black College-Educated Lawyer for Liberia
- Louis Charles Roudanez (1823-1890)
- DMS Class of 1857Physician, publisher of the first black daily newspaper in the U.S., Civil Rights leader and politician
- William Baldwin Ellis (1834-1866)
- DMS Class of 1858, M.D.Physician and Civil War acting assistant surgeon
- William Henry Furniss (1846-1920)
- Class of 1862Assistant to secretary of state of Mississippi, educator, and government postal worker
- John Randall Blackburn (1841-1937)
- Class of 1863Professor, educator and university trustee
- Benjamin Antony Boseman, Jr. (1840-1881)
- DMS Class of 1863Physician, Civil War surgeon, South Carolina Reconstruction-era politician, and federal postmaster
- Richard Henry Green (1833-1877)
- DMS Class of 1864, M.D.Physician in upstate New York